Join the Club: unlock exclusive food and drink deals across Ireland.
Food Stories - 3 Minute Read

For flip’s sake

Share:FacebookXWhatsApp
For flip’s sake

Has Pancake Tuesday gone too fancy? In defence of lemon and sugar.

Pancake Tuesday has become a rather elaborate affair. A quick look at social media reveals towering stacks of American-style pancakes, elaborate chocolate creations, whipped cream, pistachio spreads and enough maple syrup to fill a small swimming pool.

All very impressive. But for plenty of households in Ireland and Northern Ireland, the perfect pancake still involves three things: a frying pan, a lemon and a bag of sugar.

And perhaps someone shouting, "Is mine ready yet?"

The pancakes we remember

For most of us, Pancake Tuesday wasn't about a leisurely brunch or a carefully styled breakfast plate. It was an evening operation, usually involving one person standing over the cooker while everyone else waited for their turn.

By the third or fourth, things generally improved.

The pancakes themselves were thin, more like French crêpes than the fluffy American versions now filling café menus.

They were sprinkled with sugar, given a squeeze of lemon, rolled up and eaten immediately, and there was very little ceremony involved (apart from the occasional argument over whose turn was next.)

The pancakes we remember
The first pancake was often a write-off. Too thick, too thin, stuck to the pan or folded over itself during an overambitious attempt at flipping.

How did pancakes get so fancy?

Chocolate spread is practically a standard option. Biscoff, salted caramel, banana, strawberries and marshmallows regularly make an appearance.

Then there are the American-style stacks, often topped with bacon and maple syrup, which have become a familiar sight on brunch menus across Ireland.

There's nothing wrong with any of them, of course. A fluffy pancake with good butter and maple syrup is a fine thing. But they are quite different from the pancakes many of us grew up eating.

For one thing, the traditional thin pancake was rarely considered a full meal. It was more of an opportunity to eat several pancakes in quick succession and then wonder why you felt so full.

How did pancakes get so fancy?
These days, it's difficult to find a topping that hasn't appeared on a pancake.

Member offers

Deals for you

1 / 5

Relevant local offers give readers another way to act on what they have discovered.

What about savoury pancakes?

If you're willing to look beyond dessert, pancakes make an excellent base for savoury fillings. Cheese and mushrooms work particularly well, especially with a little mustard or cream.

Ham and cheddar is another dependable combination, while smoked salmon and cream cheese can turn a simple pancake into something you'd happily serve for lunch.

You could even use thin pancakes in place of pasta sheets for a baked dish with spinach, ricotta and tomato sauce.

Admittedly, that's a bit more effort than squeezing half a lemon over one.

The great topping divide

There are probably three broad camps when it comes to Pancake Tuesday.

The traditionalists, who believe lemon and sugar is all anyone should ever need.

The chocolate enthusiasts, who consider pancakes a perfectly reasonable excuse to eat something resembling dessert for dinner.

And the adventurous crowd, who are happy to experiment with everything from savoury cheese fillings to caramelised fruit.

The real question is whether any of these modern toppings have managed to replace lemon and sugar in our affections.

Probably not entirely. It's cheap, simple and the sharpness of the lemon cuts through the sweetness rather nicely.

There's also a strong nostalgic argument in its favour.

Of course, you could always make a few different varieties this Pancake Tuesday.

Just don't volunteer to be the person standing at the cooker making them all.

And whatever you do, don't let anyone persuade you that flipping the pancake is essential. A spatula works perfectly well.

The great topping divide
Some foods taste best when they're exactly as you remember them.
Love Your Food Club

Choose your membership

Membership options are temporarily unavailable. Please try again shortly.

View membership options